BY KATHRYN LEGER, FREELANCE MARCH 12, 2010
Moshe Krasnanski is not a lawyer, but he knows plenty about different concepts of law, notably Jewish civil law - the multiple life-governing facets of the Talmud, the massive compilation of oral teachings in written form and commentaries on them that is the central text for mainstream Judaism.
Before being ordained in his native New York as a rabbi - by another rabbi who, as per tradition, was ordained by another rabbi before him and so on generations back - he spent the better part of each day for 10 years studying the Talmud.
The learning continues, and now Krasnanski is taking his dedication to imparting how every aspect of daily life is infused by that doctrine to a new level by orchestrating the teaching of a special course that compares ancient Talmudic texts with Quebec civil law.
This week, Krasnanski wrapped up the first series of six such comparative sessions on topics ranging from business ethics and property rights to employment practices. He works out of the community centre Chabad of the Town (Town of Mount Royal), where he is executive director.
"It was an eye-opener for me," said Krasnanski, who taught and designed teaching programs in the United States before moving here 15 years ago. "Civil law is in many ways much closer to a lot of the Jewish law than common law (the legal system in the U.S. and elsewhere in Canada)."
Krasnanski obtained approval from the Quebec Bar to offer the course for credits under its mandatory continuing legal education (CLE) program that, since April of last year, requires that Quebec lawyers obtain 30 CLE credits each two years.
Building on a CLE course offered through the worldwide Jewish Learning Institute in many U.S. states and in British Columbia - jurisdictions where the common law tradition prevails - Krasnanski recruited local lawyers from big and small Montreal law firms to look at Talmudic interpretations of rights and wrongs defined by rabbis - in most cases a few hundred years ago - and explain to participants how the same issues might legally play out under the Quebec Civil Code.
Take the case of rights if a neighbouring property was sold.
Under Talmudic legal tradition, the neighbour next door would have the right to buy the property if it was sold to someone else, an inherent concept of social justice, the rabbi said.
Under the Quebec Civil Code, Spiegel Sohmer LLP litigator Barry Landy explained, there is a different but similar provision for undivided ownership when more than one person owns a property (other than a condo). Any co-owner of an undivided property, within 60 days of learning that his or her share was sold to someone else, has the right to buy out that person.
"We have our own concept of social justice (in Quebec) because, according to the Civil Code, everybody has to perform their obligations in good faith, and there are all kinds of provisions where neighbours have duties to each other," Landy said.
While the Talmudic comparison may seem esoteric, Jeff Orenstein, an Orenstein and Associates litigator, said learning other legal concepts "broadens your ideas and your foundation of law."
"If you read the Civil Code, it doesn't mean anything unless you understand the concepts behind it, which goes back to Roman law and was influenced by a lot of legal systems. The more you learn, the more you understand your own legal system," Orenstein said.
"It is amazing to think that a system that was created almost 2,000 years ago would, generally speaking, have the same kind of solutions to particular problems that we have almost 2,000 years later," said Yoine Goldstein, a McMillan LLP insolvency specialist and comparative law aficionado who attended some of the sessions.
"The Talmud does not enunciate principles like the Civil Code does," Goldstein said. "It gives very specific examples and points out what various rabbinic authorities have said about the issue in the hope and expectation that one can extrapolate and then apply to other similar situations. Our system of (civil) law goes from the general to the specific. You have an enunciation of the principles, but no specific cases and the assumption is you apply those principles to specific situations, so it makes for a very interesting study of different legal systems."
Other lawyers taking the challenge of giving presentations to more than 75 lawyers attending included class-action lawyer Irwin I. Liebman of Liebman and Associates; Stikeman Elliott LLP's Patrick Essiminy, an employment and labour law specialist; Mortimer G. Freiheit, a litigator specializing in representing financial institutions; and Mark Potechin, a tax lawyer with Phillips Friedman Kotler LLP.
More comparative discoveries of similarities and differences will be forthcoming, Krasnanski said.
A full list of the other continuing legal education courses for lawyers is available at: www.barreau.qc.ca/registre-activites-reconnues
If you have any information to share about the legal community, send it to strictlylegal@ymail.com
In the Media |
 |
 |
Naperville Sun Wednesday, Nov 3rd, 2010
|
 |
J-Wire Tuesday, Nov 2nd, 2010
|
 |
The News-Press, Southwest Florida Tuesday, Nov 2nd, 2010
|
 |
The Rice Thresher Monday, Nov 1st, 2010
|
 |
Jewishinstlouis.org Wednesday, Oct 27th, 2010
|
 |
NY Blueprint Tuesday, Oct 26th, 2010
|
 |
Winnipeg Jewish Review Tuesday, Oct 26th, 2010
|
 |
North South Brunswick Sentinel Tuesday, Oct 26th, 2010
|
 |
Vail Daily News Tuesday, Oct 26th, 2010
|
 |
Miami's Community Newspapers Monday, Oct 18th, 2010
|
 |
South African Jewish Report Thursday, Oct 14th, 2010
|
 |
St. Louis Jewish Light Thursday, Oct 14th, 2010
|
 |
Norwich Bulletin Thursday, Oct 14th, 2010
|
 |
Swampscott Reporter Thursday, Oct 14th, 2010
|
 |
J-Wire Thursday, Oct 14th, 2010
|
 |
Warwick Beacon Thursday, Oct 14th, 2010
|
 |
Jewish Ledger Thursday, Oct 14th, 2010
|
 |
Reston Connection Thursday, Oct 14th, 2010
|
 |
TribLocal.com Tuesday, Sep 14th, 2010
|
 |
lubavitch.com Tuesday, Sep 14th, 2010
|
 |
Sparta Independent Friday, May 14th, 2010
|
 |
The Vancouver Sun Monday, May 10th, 2010
|
 |
Stockton Record Thursday, Apr 29th, 2010
|
 |
Skokie Review Thursday, Apr 29th, 2010
|
 |
Jewish Review Wednesday, Apr 28th, 2010
|
 |
Jewish Press of Tampa Wednesday, Apr 28th, 2010
|
 |
Roseville Press Tribune Monday, Apr 26th, 2010
|
 |
Summit Daily News Monday, Apr 26th, 2010
|
 |
Jewish Review Monday, Apr 26th, 2010
|
 |
Lubavitch.com Monday, Apr 26th, 2010
|
 |
Madison Eagle Monday, Apr 26th, 2010
|
 |
Beliefnet.com Monday, Apr 26th, 2010
|
 |
SILive.com Monday, Apr 26th, 2010
|
 |
Boulder Jewish News Wednesday, Apr 14th, 2010
|
 |
Santa Barbara News-Press Wednesday, Apr 14th, 2010
|
 |
Daily Record Wednesday, Apr 14th, 2010
|
 |
5 Towns Jewish Times Wednesday, Apr 14th, 2010
|
 |
TheAlternativePress.com Wednesday, Apr 14th, 2010
|
 |
SILive.com Wednesday, Apr 14th, 2010
|
 |
5 Towns Jewish Times Thursday, Apr 1st, 2010
|
 |
Toledo Blade Monday, Feb 8th, 2010
|
 |
Hartford Courant Tuesday, Feb 2nd, 2010
|
 |
Norwich Bulletin Monday, Feb 1st, 2010
|
 |
Cincinnati.com Monday, Feb 1st, 2010
|
 |
Asheville Citizen-Times Wednesday, Jan 27th, 2010
|
 |
Westchester.com Wednesday, Jan 27th, 2010
|
 |
Vail Daily News Wednesday, Jan 27th, 2010
|
 |
Jewish Press of Pinellas County Wednesday, Jan 27th, 2010
|
 |
New Jersey Jewish Standard Tuesday, Jan 26th, 2010
|
 |
Madison Eagle Monday, Jan 25th, 2010
|
 |
NorthJersey.com Wednesday, Jan 20th, 2010
|
 |
Recorder Community Newspapers Tuesday, Jan 19th, 2010
|
 |
The Alternative Press Monday, Jan 18th, 2010
|
 |
Cincinnati.Com Wednesday, Jan 13th, 2010
|
 |
Florida Sun Sentinel Wednesday, Jan 13th, 2010
|
 |
Friday, Dec 18th, 2009
|
 |
Jewish Times of Southern New Jersey Friday, Dec 11th, 2009
|
 |
Lubavitch.com Thursday, Dec 3rd, 2009
|
 |
Lower Hudson Journal news Wednesday, Dec 2nd, 2009
|
 |
Daily Breeze Monday, Nov 30th, 2009
|
 |
JackCentral - Flagstaff, AZ Thursday, Nov 19th, 2009
|
 |
Jewish Press - August 2009 Wednesday, Nov 18th, 2009
|
 |
Toledo Blade Monday, Nov 9th, 2009
|
 |
Charlotte Sun Thursday, Nov 5th, 2009
|
 |
The Westender - Brisbane's Urban Voice www.westender.com.au Thursday, Oct 29th, 2009
|
 |
The Westender - Brisbane's Urban Voice www.westender.com.au Thursday, Oct 29th, 2009
|
 |
Cincinnati.com Thursday, Oct 29th, 2009
|
 |
YourNepean.com Wednesday, Oct 28th, 2009
|
 |
NJ.com Wednesday, Oct 28th, 2009
|
 |
Orlando Judaism Examiner Friday, Oct 23rd, 2009
|
 |
SILive.com Friday, Oct 23rd, 2009
|
 |
The Riverdale Press Thursday, Oct 22nd, 2009
|
 |
Asheville Citizen-Times Wednesday, Oct 21st, 2009
|
 |
The Billings Gazette Monday, Oct 19th, 2009
|
 |
The Swampscott Reporter Friday, Sep 25th, 2009
|
 |
The Westender Monday, Sep 14th, 2009
|
 |
Palm Beach Daily News Sunday, Sep 6th, 2009
|
 |
Jewish Press Thursday, May 21st, 2009
|
 |
Jewish Press Thursday, May 21st, 2009
|
 |
Jewish Press Thursday, May 21st, 2009
|
 |
Five Towns Jewish Times Online Friday, May 8th, 2009
|
 |
www.hometownlife.com Monday, May 4th, 2009
|
 |
Jewish Times of Southern New Jersey Monday, May 4th, 2009
|
 |
chicagojewishnews.com Friday, Feb 20th, 2009
|
 |
Vail Daily Monday, Feb 16th, 2009
|
 |
YourHub.com Monday, Feb 16th, 2009
|
 |
Calgary Herald Monday, Feb 9th, 2009
|
 |
The Stonington Times Thursday, Feb 5th, 2009
|
 |
NJ.com Somerset Wednesday, Feb 4th, 2009
|
 |
baltimoresun.com Wednesday, Feb 4th, 2009
|
 |
NJ.com Wednesday, Feb 4th, 2009
|
 |
Wednesday, Jan 28th, 2009
|
 |
silive.com Monday, Jan 26th, 2009
|
 |
Westender-Brisbane Monday, Jan 26th, 2009
|
 |
Jewish Times of Southern New Jersey Wednesday, Jan 21st, 2009
|
 |
wickedLocal.com- Swamscott Tuesday, Jan 20th, 2009
|
 |
Chabad Jewish Learning Institute of Winnipeg Tuesday, Jan 20th, 2009
|
 |
silive.com Monday, Jan 19th, 2009
|
 |
Jewish Times-SJ Monday, Jan 19th, 2009
|
 |
Baltimore Jewish Times - November 7, 2008 Thursday, Jan 1st, 2009
|
 |
The Gazette (Montreal) Thursday, Dec 11th, 2008
|
 |
Greater Media Newspapers Thursday, Dec 11th, 2008
|
 |
Toledo Blade Thursday, Dec 11th, 2008
|
 |
jewishinstlouis.org Thursday, Dec 11th, 2008
|
 |
Daily Pilot Thursday, Dec 11th, 2008
|
 |
Singapore Outreach Program Thursday, Dec 11th, 2008
|
 |
The Westender Thursday, Dec 11th, 2008
|
 |
Vail Daily News Thursday, Dec 11th, 2008
|
 |
The Tennessean Thursday, Dec 11th, 2008
|
 |
Calgary Herald Thursday, Dec 11th, 2008
|
 |
Cincinnati.com Thursday, Dec 11th, 2008
|
 |
Canadian Jewish News Thursday, Dec 11th, 2008
|
 |
Student Thursday, Dec 11th, 2008
|
 |
Asheville Citizen-Times Tuesday, Nov 4th, 2008
|
 |
WESTENDER Friday, Oct 31st, 2008
|
 |
News Press Friday, Oct 31st, 2008
|
 |
Thousand Oaks Acorn Friday, Oct 31st, 2008
|
 |
The Baltimore Sun Friday, Oct 31st, 2008
|
 |
YourHub.com Friday, Oct 31st, 2008
|
 |
The Wisconsin Jewish Chronicle Friday, Oct 31st, 2008
|
 |
Jewish Press Friday, Oct 31st, 2008
|
 |
Staten Island Advance Monday, Oct 27th, 2008
|
 |
Lubavitch.com Friday, Aug 22nd, 2008
|
 |
Calgary Herald Thursday, May 15th, 2008
|
 |
Voices Tuesday, May 13th, 2008
|
 |
5 Towns Jewish Times Monday, Mar 31st, 2008
|
 |
Hunterdon County Democrat Tuesday, Feb 5th, 2008
|
 |
Calgary Herald Saturday, Feb 2nd, 2008
|
 |
www.JewishTelegraph.com Wednesday, Jan 2nd, 2008
|
 |
Town-Crier Tuesday, Jan 1st, 2008
|
 |
www.lubavitch.com Monday, Dec 31st, 2007
|
 |
The Jewish Telegraph Monday, Dec 31st, 2007
|
 |
Calgary Herald Thursday, Nov 22nd, 2007
|
 |
Arutz Sheva (www.IsraelNationalNews.com) Wednesday, Nov 21st, 2007
|
 |
www.JewishTelegraph.com Friday, Nov 9th, 2007
|
 |
Northbrook Star Thursday, Nov 1st, 2007
|
 |
http://www.heraldtribune.com/article/20071027/NEWS/710270537/1001/NEWS0105 Saturday, Oct 27th, 2007
|
 |
Tallahassee Democrat (FL) Friday, Oct 26th, 2007
|
 |
Jewish Review (Portland, OR) Friday, Oct 26th, 2007
|
 |
The Gazette (Colorado Springs) Friday, Oct 26th, 2007
|
 |
The Tennessean (Nashville, TN) Friday, Oct 26th, 2007
|
 |
CJN (Cleveland) Friday, Oct 26th, 2007
|
 |
Jewish Exponent Friday, Oct 19th, 2007
|
 |
JTA News Wire Friday, Oct 19th, 2007
|
 |
Towne Crier Online (Wellington, FL) Friday, Oct 19th, 2007
|
 |
The Reporter (Broome County, NY) Friday, Oct 19th, 2007
|
 |
Pittsburgh Jewish Chronicle Friday, Oct 19th, 2007
|
 |
The Jewish Exponent (Philadelphia) Friday, Oct 19th, 2007
|
 |
thestate.com Monday, Oct 15th, 2007
|
 |
The Atlanta Jewish Times Monday, Oct 15th, 2007
|
 |
Westchester.com Monday, Oct 15th, 2007
|
 |
The Jewish Review Sunday, Oct 7th, 2007
|
 |
The Jewish Review Sunday, Oct 7th, 2007
|
 |
Monday, Aug 20th, 2007
|
 |
Pocono Record Wednesday, Nov 8th, 2006
|
 |
Pocono Record Wednesday, Nov 8th, 2006
|
 |
Daily Camera Monday, Nov 6th, 2006
|
 |
Sun Sentinel Saturday, Sep 16th, 2006
|
 |
Washington Jewish Week Thursday, Mar 30th, 2006
|
 |
Tuesday, Mar 28th, 2006
|
 |
Wrangler News Sunday, Jan 29th, 2006
|
 |
Jewish Exponent Thursday, Dec 29th, 2005
|
 |
The Californian Wednesday, Nov 30th, 2005
|
 |
The Californian Wednesday, Nov 30th, 2005
|
 |
Newday Monday, Nov 28th, 2005
|
 |
Nassau Herald Monday, Nov 28th, 2005
|
 |
Monday, Nov 21st, 2005
|
 |
The Day Wednesday, Nov 2nd, 2005
|
 |
Thursday, Aug 11th, 2005
|
 |
Richmond Times-Dispatch - Dec 11, 2004 Thursday, Dec 30th, 2004
|
 |
Jewish News - Dec 20, 2004 Thursday, Dec 30th, 2004
|
 |
Jewish Learning Institute’s interactive course to apply ancient wisdom to modern issues Thursday, Dec 30th, 2004
|
 |
Friday, Dec 17th, 2004
|
 |
University-level adult education program utilizes text analysis to probe major dramas in the Book of Genesis Sunday, Dec 5th, 2004
|
 |
The Newtown Gazette Thursday, Oct 21st, 2004
|
 |
The Newtown Gazette Thursday, Oct 21st, 2004
|
 |
Friday, Oct 15th, 2004
|
 |
Jewish Reflector - October issue Monday, Sep 27th, 2004
|
 |
Jewish News - Sept. Edition Monday, Sep 27th, 2004
|
 |
Richmond Times Dispatch, Sept. 18, 2004 Monday, Sep 27th, 2004
|
|
|